• Everyday Staff Page
  • Forum
  • Game Review Index
  • GamingAngels & the Press
  • GamingAngels Affiliates
  • GamingAngels Presents Network
  • Write for GA
  • Subscribe
GamingAngels   
  • Home
  • Pop Culture
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV
      • Blood Angels
    • Web Trends
    • Fashion
    • Toys
  • Game Reviews
    • Xbox 360
    • PS3
    • Wii
    • PC
    • DS
    • PSP
    • PS2
  • Gadget Angels
    • Gadget
    • Mobile
  • Angel Life
    • GA Presents
  • Turning Japanese
  • Pulp Angels
    • Super Angels
  • Casual Gaming
    • Casual Game Reviews
    • Casual Game News
    • Facebook Games
  • Featured
  • Hobby Angels
  • Angels on the Go
    • E3 2009
    • E3 2010
    • E3 2011
  • Geek Women
    • Women in Games
    7 Comments   
Fri, Oct 30 2009 | Published in Angel Life, Featured, News

Breast Cancer Awareness Not Welcome in Forza 3

By: Yukino

Tweet

tatasstickerIn this day and age, one would like to believe that they are doing good by promoting and supporting a cause such as breast cancer, especially during breast cancer awareness month.

Unfortunately, an Xbox Live user’s “Save the Ta Tas” Susan G Komen bumper sticker which was selling in the Auction House/Store Front for the newly released Forza 3 ended up in the user being banned for violating the Xbox Live terms of service. And it wasn’t even the Xbox team that banned him, it was the fellows at Turn10, the game’s developer.

This logo is available to buy on Amazon, is on t-shirts, bumper stickers, keychains, magnets, socks. You name it, its on it. Breasts are a part of the human anatomy and the word is a commonly used one. Everyone sees them, they stick out from our shirts.

But for some reason this word is censored from use on Xbox Live and is deemed offensive. Apparently, so is the term ta ta.

While I understand that certain words can be used in a very offensive matter, I still do not believe in a blanket ban for any person who chooses to use these terms. There is a moderation team in place, and as human beings, I would have thought that the people on these teams would look at each case individually. If they thought that what was being posted could possibly be deemed offensive, why not shoot that user a warning message, asking them to politely remove the content so as not to ban them instead of blindly hitting the suspension button?

Yes, I know the Terms of Service are there for a reason. But isn’t it possible that there is such a thing as going to far or being a tad overzealous with the rules? Agreed, no one wants to be tangled up in a lawsuit, but in this case who in their right mind is going to be offended by one of the most common marketing campaigns for a serious women’s health issue? It’s definitely not the millions of women who are affected by breast cancer and their families and friends.

Before locking the thread that was posted on the official Forza 3 forums, Turn10 posted the following:

Currently we are banning users who have created an item that contains any of the following elements:

  • Depictions of nudity and/or sexual themes and suggestions. This includes “censored” designs or items that are deemed inappropriate.
  • Depictions of racism, hate crimes, bigotry, and discrimination. This includes any references to the Nazi regime.
  • Depictions of drugs and/or narcotics.
  • Fraudulent depictions used to trick players into purchasing your item.
  • Derogatory comments or remarks targeted at another user, person, or group.
  • Offensive language and profanity.
  • Any political references that we deem as inappropriate or offensive.

How is supporting breast cancer seen as inappropriate? It seems Turn10 has decided not to comment any further on the issue, hoping that locking any more activity in the thread will silence the voices who are outraged with this turn of events.

I for one believe that Turn10 is in the wrong for removing the item and banning the user, and I hope they change their minds and apologize. As a female gamer, hell, just as a female, I find what they did offensive. I also hope they go home and tell their wives, girlfriends and daughters that they won’t openly support a cause that might one day affect their personal lives.

You can see what SLIM135 wrote on the Official Xbox Forums regarding his suspension here, or read the locked thread on the Turn10 forums here.

EDIT: So apparently Turn10 responded to Destructoid, and the user has been un-banned. They decided to look into it & found out the slogan is legit. I am still hoping for a personal response from Turn10 to GamingAngels.

Related Posts

  • PETA’s latest game: Test the Breast, Not the Rest
  • Fight like a girl, and you help fight breast cancer
  • EA Sports supports fight against Breast Cancer
  • Game Industry unites to help a woman battle Breast Cancer
  • Microsoft and Oberon Media join breast cancer fight


Tags: Breast, Breast cancer, Conditions and Diseases
Share This: Twitter Digg Stumble Upon Reddit Delicious Facebook N4G
Yukino

About Yukino

Yukino loves all things Japan. TV shows, anime, music, food. She also loves playing video games, watching lots of TV & movies, and reading. You can usually find her on Xbox Live, and almost always on Twitter. XBL: Yuki no Kokoro PSN: Yuki-Hime Twitter: yuki_hime
View all articles by Yukino
Send Email |Website
Sign in or Post as Guest
Livefyre logo
  • Comment help
  • Get Livefyre
Post comment as
twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
KagoMegan

Chalk it up to another one of the ridiculous reasons people get banned from XBL. *rolls eyes* >_>It's an issue that both men AND women need to be concerned about. Ta-ta's, unite! :)~Meg

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
red

"How is supporting breast cancer seen as inappropriate?"it might be because the use of the word "ta tas". they probably didn't bother looking into it and automatically assumed it was something offensive. the industry is run by men and they don't look into that kind of thing because they're lazy and most of the time they hate asking for directions.

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
Michael

They took down a few quasi-political statements I made on a vinyl. I made one that basically said I could not express an opinion on an economic system of Government, but I could paint nearly nude pics of girls all day long...that was taken down. So I simply wrote..."The problem with censorship is...(with a few scribbles as if two words had been blocked out). Taken down within 30 seconds...lol. How did this violate the Terms of Service? They are not too worried about the plethora of images depicting females barely clothed, in provocative positions, etc. to me, that is way offensive, and every where you look, they are in the top rated and downloaded vinyls. Turn 10 and Microsoft Game Studios has lost all my respect. What they did with the breast cancer is even more despicable!!! I wouldn't care if my 4 year old saw the breast cancer sticker, but I do care about 90% of the other vinyls that are allowed to be posted in their storefronts/auction houses.

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
green

Turn10's crack moderation team bans all sorts of other legitimate things. They put a cap on their user created content before the ball even gets rolling. I recommend avoiding Forza 3 if you want freedom of speech.

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
KagoMegan

Chalk it up to another one of the ridiculous reasons people get banned from XBL. *rolls eyes* >_>

It's an issue that both men AND women need to be concerned about. Ta-ta's, unite! :)

~Meg

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
red

"How is supporting breast cancer seen as inappropriate?"

it might be because the use of the word "ta tas". they probably didn't bother looking into it and automatically assumed it was something offensive. the industry is run by men and they don't look into that kind of thing because they're lazy and most of the time they hate asking for directions.

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
stealthyslyth

I can't believe they'd do that. I would love to see an official response

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like
amber

as someone who knows many women with breastcancer or has had it, this offends me! It just makes me want to put tatas or breast all over my xbox stuff n fight this. this is Ridiculous!

share
  • spam
  • offensive
  • disagree
  • off topic
Like

Trackbacks

  1. 10 Common-sense Self Defense Tips For Men | Olimpia Club says:
    October 30, 2009 at 7:09 pm

    [...] Breast Cancer Awareness Not Welcome in Forza 3 | GamingAngels [...]

  • Login





    Register | Lost your password?
  • Be a Fan!

    GamingAngels on Facebook
  • RSS GA Presents

    • Tattoo Tuesday- Sherlock Holmes February 7, 2012
    • TMG-240 And It Even Plays Games February 6, 2012
    • Game Dames Episode 42: And we’re back! January 11, 2012
    • PCN – PrincessCast Episode 32 March 9, 2011
  • Recent Forum Posts

    • oveceo
      Gaming Study!

      by oveceo

    • World of Popus is here!

      by aceejohson

    • Tiffany Nevin
      Maybe someone knows...

      by candybeans

    • Kaireyven
      World of Warcraft for Mac...

      by Kaireyven

    • play in style - girl gamer fashion

      by orion


  • Featured on BlogHer.com
  • join our mailing list
    * indicates required

    View previous campaigns.

    Close
  • Home
  • Game Review Index
  • GamingAngels & the Press
  • GamingAngels Affiliates
  • GamingAngels Presents Network
  • Sponsorship and Advertising
  • Write for GA

© 2004 - 2012 GamingAngels. All rights reserved. A Premium WordPress Theme Design.

Add to Technorati FavoritesbloglovinStumbleUpon Toolbar Contact us at Tips at GamingAngels.com

67 queries in 1.118 seconds.